Well, it seems that I finally have perfected my method of pita-making. I’ve had a hard time perfecting other bread recipes, but pitas always seem to work for me! So, here’s what I know now about “what makes a pita a pita.”

The first thing to understand about pita is why a flat pice of bread gets a pocket in the middle of it when you bake it. The answer: when you place moist dough in a very hot oven, the moisture in the dough turns to gas, pushes the dough out, and forms a pocket.

Homemade Pita:

  • 1 1/2 cup water
  • 3 Tbsp. sunflower oil
  • 3 3/4 cup flour
  • 1 tsp. salt
  • 1 1/2 Tbsp. yeast
  • 1 1/2 Tbsp. sugar

I should admit: I cheated and used a bread machine for the first part of the kneading process. But, since I got a bread machine, I’ve been cheating away the first 10 minutes of bread-making anyway..

So, the first step in making pita bread is having a dough that is not too dry. In past biscuit-making adventures, I’ve encountered a lot of dough that seemed very sticky. My initial response to sticky dough was to simply add more flour – not so! If you can’t work with the wet dough, then just get your hands wet as well. The dough won’t stick to your hands, and as long as you put enough flour on the surface you plan to set the dough on, you’ll be just fine. (By the way, this “moist dough” theory seems to apply to a lot of artisan breads as well).

This recipe makes 8-12 pockets, depending on how big you want them to be. As soon as you mix the dough together, cut it into 8-12 pieces (a pizza cutter works well), and then roll each pice into a round ball. Put all the balls together (not touching) on a well-floured surface, and cover with a damp dish towel. Let them sit for 30 minutes.

Roll out the balls into discs – they should be about the width of a yard stick. Place the discs onto baking sheets.

The next step: make sure that you have a HOT OVEN. The oven needs to be pre-heated to 500ºF, and every time you take cooked pita out of the oven, let the oven heat up for another minute or two before putting another sheet in. Also, I have found that it’s best to cook pita on the bottom-most rack and only cook ONE SHEET of pita breads at a time.

If the oven is hot enough and your dough is moist enough, your pitas should puff up in the oven. Don’t let them cook too long – 5-7 minutes is long enough. If they start to turn brown on the top, take them out! Over-cooked pitas will crack and fall apart.

Let the pitas cool until you can touch them, and then put them into a paper bag, sealed tightly, adding each batch of pitas as you cook them. Let the pitas cool off in the bag – they will deflate, forming a flat bread with a pocket inside. Stuff, eat, yum.

3 replies on “Pita!”

  1. Ray Menke says:

    Yesterday, I prepared a batch of pita bread following your recipe (almost), using 2 1/2 c. bread flour and 1 c. rye flour, but the correct amount of water and oil. (I have a collection of pita recipes, and your recipe did call for a bit more oil, and a bit more water than most.) I cooked these over a Top lit updraft gasifier (TLUD) out on the patio one-at-a-time using a large 12″ cast iron skillet coated with canola oil. (smoking hot!) Each of the 12 pitas rose up about 2 1/2″ to 3″ making the best batch of them I have ever made! Dark brown with a touch of black here and there. Very Good. Thanks for posting this on your blog. It is a keeper! Ray, in Lytton Springs, TX.

  2. Ray Menke says:

    Regarding the Pita Breads, I now make 32 at a time, and store some of them in the freezer. I’m still using your recipe. My wife and I made a YouTube video of the process of making them over a wood gas stove using two cast iron pans. Under the YouTube description is a little pull-down menu that has quite a bit of information, as well as a link to download the (now) two pages of recipe and the “how to”. Looking at my previous reply, I see that we have been making these regularly for almost two years. Ray, in Lytton Springs, TX (I used to live in what is now called Andover, MN)

  3. jessi gurr says:

    I’m glad you like them! We live close to Andover; small world ;)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *